160m mobile antenna in a loft

Wow, FT8 is very forgiving but at dusk I worked PA0TCA, near Rotterdam, which must be 300 miles or so!

Determined to be active on 160m again but remain stealthy with only loft antennas my choice fwas either a mag loop or a 160m mobile whip with a loading coil. Both antennas would be very inefficient, probably no better than 0.5%. A mag loop would probably be quieter but expensive and complicated so simplicity won out in the end…

I bought a AmPro-160m from Moonraker. It has a mid section loading coil with a tunable whip length. It’s actually a little more than 2m high and so the whip section will have to be bent in my loft to be a mini inverted-L.  The antenna has a vSWR rating of <2 within a bandwidth of 15kHz. Although any ATUs would stretch that it gets even more inefficient so my plan will be to set up for an area of the band and with minimal ATU intervention to cover around 30kHz.

Plan A – didn’t work as expected

My antenna analyser showed the antenna with the original whip section to be tunable between around 1890kHz and 2000kHz. It might improve a little when in situ in the loft but I decided to dispense with the sprung steel whip and use multicore speaker wire for the whip instead. I decided to use a static section of wire with a chocolate block screw connector to connect frequency specific (wavelength specific) wire tails to it (shown below). All the connections were tinned with solder of course to stop them fraying when changing tails.

160m-whip-tails

This approach seemed fine until I tried it in the loft and found SWR was > 5! There seems to be a lot of interaction with my other antennas and possibly a ground loop issue with the coax braid for this antenna against other antennas.

Plan B – progress but scope for improvement

This mobile antenna doesn’t have a big lump of a vehicle underneath it when its in the loft of course. I made these changes:-

  1. Isolate the metal ground planes I was using for this antenna and my 6-2-70 colinear antenna. I thought a ground loop might be happening here so giving each antenna its own ground plane seemed a good move.
  2. I created a ground plane out of builders yard materials with a steel matrix sheet (roughly 1 foot x 3 foot) for the antenna mag mount to sit on and then two sections of 8 foot steel angle bead lengths (roughly 2″ wide bent at 90 degrees in the centre) bolted to the matrix sheet running out at 180 degrees to each other. This made the ground plane 16′ long although quite thin of course.

I tested again. SWR is now > 4.

I had a go on FT8 on 1840kHz running 20w and worked PA0TCA near Rotterdam (I gave -4, I received -20).